We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

The 10 Best Weed Killers of 2024

Reduce the tedious time spent weeding your garden

In This Article

In This Article

Person spraying Green Gobbler 20% Vinegar Weed Killer on weeds

The Spruce / Katie Begley 

While all gardens require occasional weeding to cut down on unwanted plant growth, some gardeners find that they have to spend far more time than they'd like to remove weeds. For those situations, many gardeners turn to weed killers to get the task done quickly and easily, especially when needing to deal with weeds in the lawn.

Most weed killers effectively kill the common broad-leaf weeds, such as dandelions, thistle, crabgrass, and spurge. However, some formulations are more effective against certain weeds than others, so if you are trying to eliminate a specific type of weed, check the product label to be sure it’s listed. 

If you have weeds on walkways or patios, look for a non-selective weed killer. These herbicides are not safe for use on lawns since they kill any greenery they touch. If you have weeds in your lawn, consider selective herbicides that target specific weeds but generally do not kill common types of lawn grass. This is the type of weed killer commonly found in weed and feed lawn fertilizers and similar products.

We evaluated numerous weed killers from major brands. In each case, we considered the weed killer's toxicity, the types of weeds it eradicates, its safety for use around people and pets, its versatility throughout the garden, and its overall ease of use.

Best Overall

Spectracide Weed and Grass Killer

Spectracide Weed and Grass Killer Concentrate

Amazon

What We Like
  • Kills weeds and grasses at the root

  • Safe to replant in treated areas after 24 hours

  • Rainproof after 15 minutes

  • Starts to work within hours

What We Don't Like
  • Pump sprayer recommended (not included)

  • Can kill unprotected grass and other plants

We love this highly effective weed killer from Spectracide; you'll start to see targeted weeds and grasses wilting and dying within a mere 3 hours of application. This is a non-selective weed killer, so it's not suited for use on lawns, but works wonders when sprayed on weeds and unwanted grasses by sidewalks, along fences, and poking up out of driveways.

It kills most weeds, including poison ivy, dandelion, clover, and grass that's sprouting in spots where it's unwanted. And you can be sure that the treated weed is dead all the way down to the root, so no worries it will grow back again.

The weed killer comes in a concentrated form that needs to be mixed with water and applied using a tank sprayer or other spray container. If applying it near flowers or other greenery that you don't want to kill, be sure to use a piece of cardboard or plastic to protect them from the spray. Do not use this product near food crops, such as vegetables or fruits, and do not spray it on weeds in your lawn, as it will kill the lawn grass along with the weeds.

For best results, spray when the air temperature is above 60 degrees; the warmer the weather, the faster the results. Within 15 minutes of application, the weed killer will be absorbed well enough that rain won't wash it away, and if you want to plant new flowers or greenery in the treated area, you only need to wait 24 hours before it's safe to do so. However, do not let your pets or children near treated areas for at least 24 hours, and do not mow, cut, or otherwise disturb treated vegetation for a week after application.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds and grasses︱Rain Resistance Within: 15 minutes︱Results Within: 3 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: Diquat Dibromide︱Volume: 64 ounces

Is Weed Killer Safe for Pets?

Many chemical weed killers have long-lasting residual effects on the applied-to areas. Pet owners should use caution when applying such products to places where their pets are likely to walk or lounge since they could ingest the chemical directly or by licking their paws and fur.

Organic weed killer may be a better option since its compounds tend to break down more rapidly and are absorbed by the ground. However, it is still important to read the directions for use and consider the warning label on any products you use since the potential effects can vary based on the active ingredients of each formula.

Best Budget

Ortho Weed B Gon Chickweed, Clover & Oxalis Killer for Lawns

Ortho Weed B Gon Chickweed Clover & Oxalis Killer for Lawns

Amazon

What We Like
  • Targets tough weeds such as dandelions

  • Rainproof within an hour

What We Don't Like
  • Takes a long time for results

  • Not safe for all turf grasses

This reasonably priced herbicide comes as a concentrate that must be mixed with water—one 16-ounce bottle will treat up to 3,200 square feet of lawn. Note that this is a selective herbicide, so you can safely kill weeds growing in the lawn without fear of damaging common lawn grasses. It's safe for use on buffalo grass, all types of fescue, Kentucky bluegrass, ryegrass, and zoysiagrass. However, do not use it on Bermuda grass, St. Augustine, or centipede grass.

When mixed and applied with a hose sprayer or tank sprayer, it will effectively kill most common lawn weeds, including dandelions, clover, chickweed, oxalis, and spurge. Once applied, this herbicide is resistant to rain within an hour, but be aware that it is not especially fast-acting, so it could be a week or more before you notice that the weeds are turning brown and dying. Still, it gets the job done and kills the weeds down to the roots, so regrowth shouldn't be a problem.

For best results, spray on a windless day when the temperature is between 50 and 90 degrees, and keep your kids and pets off the treated lawn for at least 24 hours. Do not mow the grass for 2 days before and after applying the herbicide.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf lawn weeds ︱Rain Resistance Within: 6 hours︱Results Within: 2-3 weeks︱Primary Active Ingredient: 8% Triclopyr, Triethylamine Salt︱Volume: 16 ounces

Best for Gravel

Ortho GroundClear

Ortho GroundClear Year Long Vegetation Killer

Amazon

What We Like
  • Very effective

  • Keeps working for 1 year

  • Results within 3 hours

What We Don't Like
  • Can harm grass and desirable plants

If you've been battling weeds popping up through your gravel walkways or driveway or are tired of trying to pull weeds and grasses out of other hardscape, then you'll love how effectively this non-selective herbicide kills weeds right down to the root. Like our best overall pick, you'll start to see results in just 3 hours.

Unlike many formulas intended for hardscapes, it contains no harmful glyphosate. Because it is pre-emergent and post-emergent, this product kills existing greenery and stops seeds from sprouting for up to one year. Use it exclusively in areas where you do not intend to grow any type of plant.

Follow the package directions to mix the concentrate with water and apply with a sprayer on a windless day when the temperature is above 60 degrees. It will be rain-resistant within an hour, but be sure to keep pets and kids away from the treated area for at least 24 hours.

Use a piece of cardboard or plastic to protect any nearby plants or lawn. GroundClear will kill most broad-leaf plants, including common weeds, grasses, including lawn grass, and ornamental plants, such as ivy.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds, plants, and grasses ︱Rain Resistance Within: 1 hour ︱Results Within: 3 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: Imazapyr, isopropylamine salt: 0.47%, Pelargonic Acid and arelated fatty acids: 5.00%︱Volume: 32 ounces

Best for Lawns

Southern Ag Amine 2,4-D

Southern Ag Amine 2,4-D

Amazon

What We Like
  • Effective against many hard-to-get-rid-of weeds

  • Works on most grass types

What We Don't Like
  • Drift can damage nearby desirable plants

  • Not safe for St. Augustine lawns

This powerful weed killer from Southern Ag is selective, meaning it only targets broad-leafed weeds but is safe for most common types of lawn grass, with the exception of St. Augustine. It quickly kills all sorts of tough weeds, including thistle, dandelion, ivy, clover, and spurge; you'll start to see results in 48 hours (the longest on our list).

Mix the concentrate with water following the manufacturer's directions, and apply with a tank or hand sprayer, taking care to avoid any overspray or drift onto nearby ornamental or food crops, as the herbicide can burn or even kill desirable plants easily if spray settles onto them. For best results, spray on a warm, still day in spring or summer when weeds are actively growing. If there are new or persistent weeds, you can reapply the herbicide 30 days later, but do not use it more than twice a year.

After 48 hours, the weed killer is rain-resistant. Do not allow children or pets to walk on the treated grass for at least 24 hours. You can also use this highly potent weed killer for spot-treating weeds or to clear out weeds from ditches, along fences, or other non-grassy areas.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds ︱Rain Resistance Within: 48 hours︱Results Within: 48 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: DMA Salt of 2,4-dichlorphenoxy acetic acid︱Volume: 32 ounces

Best Natural

Green Gobbler Vinegar Weed Killer

Green Gobbler 20% Vinegar Weed Killer

Amazon

What We Like
  • Contains no harsh chemicals

  • Can be used in various places

  • No dilution needed

What We Don't Like
  • Weeds need to be pulled for best results

To eliminate weeds and grasses without harming the environment, utilize Green Gobbler Vinegar Weed and Grass Killer. We tested this weed killer and found that this solution works well on a variety of surfaces, including concrete, mulch, flower beds, roadways, and sidewalks. Furthermore, we found that weeds did not come back even after a few weeks had passed since application. It should be noted, though, that in order to make sure the weeds didn't return after being killed, we had to pull them out by hand.

This product is created without synthetic substances and is glyphosate-free, in contrast to many other weed killers that include harsh chemicals. This herbicide is highly effective against a wide variety of weeds, including crabgrass, dandelion, clover weed, white clover, mildew, and many more.

You can expect noticeable results in less than 24 hours. Keep in mind that this product's vinegar basis makes it non-weed specific and potentially harmful to all plants and grass. So, be careful not to apply it to plants you intend to maintain; rather, use it exclusively in weedy areas. If you're seeking for a green and efficient weed killer, we think this product is a fantastic pick.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Crabgrass, dandelions, and other listed weeds︱Rain Resistance Within: Not listed︱Results Within: 24 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: Acetic acid︱Volume: 1 gallon

Bottle of Green Gobbler 20% Vinegar Weed Killer displayed on concrete with instructions and spray nozzle

The Spruce / Katie Begley

Best for Flower Beds

Roundup Weed and Grass Killer

Roundup Ready-to-Use Weed and Grass Killer

The Home Depot

What We Like
  • Protective cover on wand

  • Ready-to-use

  • Fast results

What We Don't Like
  • Active ingredient is Glyphosate

If bothersome weeds are sprouting up in your flower beds or in other areas where desirable plants are in close proximity, then we recommend this highly effective weed killer from Roundup. This weed killer is a ready-to-use product with a unique "Sure Shot" wand that makes it easy to accurately target only the weed that you want to kill while protecting nearby greenery from overspray or drift.

The wand extends to 2 feet, so you don't even have to crouch down to spray the offending weed. And no bother with mixing or measuring; just pick up the container and go. It's most effective when used on days with temperatures between 60 and 85 degrees.

This non-selective herbicide quickly kills most broad-leaf weeds and grasses, and you'll see results in as little as 3 hours. The spray is also rain-resistant in a mere 10 minutes. However, be sure to keep your pets and children out of treated areas for at least a day to be sure the herbicide is entirely dry. You can also use this potent spray to kill weeds along driveways, around mulched trees, or popping up through gravel. Wherever you use it, you'll soon see the weeds dead right down to the roots.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds and grasses ︱Rain Resistance Within: 10 minutes︱Results Within: 3 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: Glyphosate︱Volume: 1.33 gallons

Best for Driveways

Roundup Extended Control Weed and Grass Killer

Roundup Extended Control Weed and Grass Killer

Amazon

What We Like
  • No mixing required

  • Comfortable, long spray wand

  • Fast results

What We Don't Like
  • Active ingredient is Glyphosate

Eradicate weeds and keep them from coming back for up to four months with this potent weed killer. Like our best for gravel pick, it combines pre- and post-emergent ingredients to prevent weed seeds from sprouting and kill existing weeds all the way down to the root.

There is no need to mix, measure, or get out your sprayer. Like the product we recommend for flower beds, it has a "Comfort Wand" applicator that makes it easier to spray without bending over. All it takes is a pull of the trigger to start spraying again.

Note that this herbicide is not for use in garden beds or on lawns. It's formulated for use on driveways, walkways, patios, and other hardscaped areas. It can also be used on gravel or decorative walk areas, as well as along curbs, fences, and retaining walls.

Wherever you use it, you'll see results in as little as 3 hours. It effectively kills the most common weeds, including poison ivy, oak, spurge weed, dandelion, thistle, and clover. It's rain-resistant in as little as 10 minutes, but keep pets and people away from treated areas until they're completely dry, and avoid letting the spray contact your lawn or desirable plants.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds and grasses ︱Rain Resistance Within: 10 minutes︱Results Within: 3 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: Glyphosate, pelargonic acid︱Volume: 1.33 gallons

Best for Gardens

Natural Armor All-Natural Weed and Grass Killer

Natural Armor All-Natural Weed and Grass Killer

Amazon

What We Like
  • Safe for use throughout the garden

  • No mixing required

What We Don't Like
  • Not safe for lawns

This organic weed killer is ideal for use throughout your garden, including flower beds, vegetable gardens, around mulched trees and shrubs, and along hardscaped areas. Keep in mind that you shouldn't use this product on grass.

This product's all-natural ingredients include salt, vinegar, and citrus oil. It's ready to use, as well, and comes with a non-clog trigger top. If you have a tank sprayer, you may also pour it into that. Either way, the product handily kills just about any broad-leaf weed or grass within 24 hours.

When using it in your garden beds, be sure to protect nearby plants with a piece of cardboard or plastic to prevent accidental contact. For best results, spray on a day without wind or rain in the forecast and with temperatures above 65 degrees.

Once sprayed, it will be rain-resistant within 24 hours. You might notice an odor of vinegar, but it will fade quickly. Although this is made without harmful ingredients, as with any potent product, keeping people and pets out of treated areas until completely dry is best.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds and grasses ︱Rain Resistance Within: 24 hours︱Results Within: 24 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: vinegar, citrus oil, salts︱Volume: 1 gallon

Best Pre-Emergent

Preen Garden Weed Preventer

Preen Garden Weed Preventer

Amazon

What We Like
  • Keeps weed seeds from sprouting for up to 3 months

  • Easy to apply

  • Not affected by rain

What We Don't Like
  • Can stain concrete or other hardscape

Most weed killers are post-emergent only, meaning that they kill only those weeds that are already growing above the soil but leave the weed seeds unscathed and ready to sprout. But this product from Preen is not pre-emergent; it does not kill weeds, as you can see, but effectively prevents their seeds from sprouting. That means that after removing weeds prior to applying the granular herbicide, you'll be freed from the tedious task of weeding for up to 3 months.

Note that Preen should not be applied on lawns, but it is excellent for use in flower beds, vegetable gardens, around trees, and underneath shrubs. Preen is effective against most common broad-leaf weeds and grasses, including purslane, foxtails, and crabgrass.

Applying it is easy. First, you'll need to remove any obvious weeds from the area. Then, sprinkle Preen across the soil evenly, following package directions for coverage. Next, gently rake the Preen into the soil, and then water it immediately to start activating its ingredients. Keep pets and kids out of the treated area until completely dry.

Rain won't wash it away once you've watered it into the soil. For best results, apply it when there is no dew or rain on your flowers or other desirable greenery to prevent the Preen granules from sticking to their leaves. You can sprinkle Preen right over mulch. If any of the granules drop onto concrete or other paving materials, sweep them up right away to prevent staining.

Application Type: Granules︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds and grasses ︱Rain Resistance Within: Immediately︱Results Within: Not applicable︱Primary Active Ingredient: Trifluralin︱Volume: 5 pounds

Best for Vegetable Gardens

Bonide Captain Jack’s Deadweed Brew

Bonide Captain Jack’s Deadweed Brew

Amazon

What We Like
  • Organic

  • Kills moss and algae as well as weeds

  • Safe for use around food crops

What We Don't Like
  • Somewhat unpleasant odor until dry

The majority of herbicides are unsafe to use near food crops like fruits and vegetables. However, this Bonide organic product changes all of that. It employs caprylic acid, an extract of coconut oil, to eliminate the majority of grasses, weeds, algae, and moss. 

Put it to use in your flower and vegetable gardens, around your trees and shrubs, and even on your hardscape, including patios and walks. But you shouldn't apply it on your grass. To use this concentrate, first combine it with water. Then, spray it straight into the weeds you want to kill, as this prevents the overspray or drift from damaging surrounding attractive vegetation.

Treated weeds will begin to noticeably die off in anywhere from 2 hours to a couple of days. It's rain-resistant within 3 hours, and you can let your pets or children into the treated areas once it's completely dry. For best results, spray on a clear, still day when temperatures are at least 40 degrees and preferably quite a bit warmer. You might notice a bit of an unpleasant odor until the spray dries, but it will dissipate after that.

Application Type: Spray︱Targeted Plants: Broad-leaf weeds, grasses, algae, moss ︱Rain Resistance Within: 3 hours︱Results Within: 2 to 48 hours︱Primary Active Ingredient: Caprylic acid︱Volume: 32 ounces

Final Verdict

Our top choice for eliminating weeds is Spectracide Weed and Grass Killer Concentrate. It can be used in a variety of areas around your property, such as flower beds, sidewalks, and even around shrubs, delivering visible results in just a few hours. For a great preventive product, the Preen Garden Weed Preventer and Plant Food gets down to the roots and stops weed seeds from sprouting for up to a year.

What to Look for in a Weed Killer

Ingredients

Most herbicides, including Ortho GroundClear, our top pick for weeds growing in gravel, have powerful active ingredients that can be harmful if they come into contact with your eyes, skin, or throat during application or while still wet. They can also be harmful to wildlife, pets, or fish.

One common active ingredient, found in Roundup, is glyphosate, a controversial chemical that has been potentially linked to adverse health effects. It’s a very effective herbicide, however. Always use caution when applying any weed killer. Ideally, you should wear protective eyewear, spray herbicide only on a clear day without wind, and immediately wash away any product that comes into contact with your skin.

There are also organic formulas that use vinegar, or derivatives of coconut oil to kill weeds. Some, including Green Gobbler 20% Vinegar Weed Killer (our best natural pick), use vinegar. Admittedly, organic herbicides do not always give results as quickly or as completely as those with more harmful ingredients, but most get the job done quite effectively.

Of course, it’s important to remember that even a seemingly benign ingredient like vinegar, which is the active ingredient in Natural Armor Weed Killer (best for gardens pick), can be harmful to your eyes or delicate skin should it come into contact with them, so be sure to use even an organic weed killer with caution.

Ease of Use

Many weed killers, including our best budget pick, the Ortho Weed B-Gon, come in a concentrated form that requires you to mix the product with water, following the manufacturer’s guidelines, before pouring the herbicide into your tank sprayer or hand sprayer for use. However, there are also ready-to-use herbicides that let you just grab the bottle and head out into the garden to battle weeds. There are also granular products that you simply sprinkle onto the ground; pre-emergent products, like Preen Garden Weed Preventer, are especially likely to come in this form. 

But whatever type of weed killer you choose, always closely follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for application. Don’t assume that the more, the better—doing so might leave you with a garden full of dead plants that you wanted to spare.

John Kauffman adds further guidelines for using weed killers safely and effectively, cautioning, “Read, understand, and follow all label directions. Apply weed control products only to areas specified on the product label. For example, some products can be used to treat weeds growing in the cracks of a driveway, while others cannot.”

Results Rate

Some weed killers are faster than others. There are products that will begin to noticeably kill weeds within a few hours—our best overall pick, Spectracide Weed and Grass Killer, starts showing results within as little as 3 hours—and others that can take days to accomplish the task. If speed is important, look for an herbicide with quick-acting results. However, remember that weeding is an ongoing garden task, so ultimately, a product that works very quickly versus a product that takes longer for full effect may not be as important to you as the types of weeds the product kills, the areas where it can be used, and its toxicity.

Weather Resistance

Many herbicides can be washed away before they fully penetrate the treated area. That means you need to pay attention to the manufacturer’s guidelines for rain-resistance or weather-resistance on the product’s label. Some weed killers, such as Roundup Extended Control (our best for driveways option), become rain-resistant in minutes, which is handy if you live in an area where rain is frequent.

Others take hours. Southern Ag Amine 2,4-D, our best for lawns pick, can take a day or so. Read all of the instructions for your chosen weed killer before applying it so you’ll know how long you need to wait before watering the treated area. John Kauffman adds that it’s very important to avoid using a weed killer on a windy day, as that can lead to product drift, which may harm or even kill plants you didn’t intend to remove.

Green Gobbler Organic 20% Vinegar Weed & Grass Killer displayed on concrete

The Spruce / Katie Begley

Why Trust The Spruce?

Michelle Ullman is a commerce writer for The Spruce who specializes in home improvement products, including tools and landscaping supplies. She has extensive experience not only in writing about all things related to the home, but also in carrying out various DIY projects, including landscaping, painting, flooring, wallpapering, furniture makeovers, and simple repairs around the house and yard. She’s also an avid gardener, and loves to spend time caring for her garden and many potted plants, both indoors and outside.

For this roundup, she considered dozens of weed killers, evaluating each for effectiveness, types of weeds killed, ease of application, toxicity, and overall value. She also considered feedback from customers, both positive and negative, as well as reviews and information on various gardening and lawn care websites.

Our Experts:

The Spruce uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
  1. Questions and Answers on Glyphosate. U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

  2. Herbicides. United States Environmental Protection Agency.

Advertisement